When logic fails and
Law of Effect saves: Reverence for daily opinion is how we take the
conclusions of others as our own premises. We, the civilized, live in a
funhouse: the conclusions we draw from each other often thrill or terrify us without
any real basis or corresponding outcome. Nonetheless, civilization herself is subordinate to nature, fencing off only the awareness of the wild. In immediate distraction, we distance awareness
from real, immediate risks. So while it is true that the examination of each up
and down of daily opinion begins with unstable premises, it is also true that not
using the butterflies in one’s stomach as an
impulse for examination is the only way to have a great time on an
unfinished rollercoaster.
turning points, The Mechanics of Virtue, aphorism 322
322 When we attempt to engineer a future event, we demand complete research, “complete” being defined as not exceeding nor falling short of all details related to our aim and obtainable within our time limit. There is much that must be excluded. Thus our research requires a strategic ignorance. But the research is still not the plan. We have yet to cull out of the totality of facts simple “turning points” calculated to accommodate human behavior, and of course only on condition that they increase the probability of our success. We often have to impose a simplicity upon a reality that does not in any way merit the slightest implication of being simplistic. If our standard of excellence places greater value on the successful execution of the strategy than on our talent for detailing the problem, then here too we condemn the intellect to a strategic ignorance. Of course, it is true that simplicity is not necessarily the same thing as clarity, and can often be its opposite...